Artifact World Gallery
Get the iOS app

Both Members of This Club by Bellows, George

Bellows, George · 1909

In 1909 New York, public boxing was illegal, leading to clandestine matches like the one depicted in George Bellows' "Both Members of This Club." This oil on canvas, housed at the National Gallery of Art, offers a visceral glimpse into an underground sporting world.

Bellows masterfully captures the raw intensity of the fight, from the grimacing face of one boxer to the taut muscles of the other. Yet, the crowd's varied reactions, from gleeful to concerned, add layers to the scene, highlighting the voyeuristic thrill of these hidden events.

The artist attended fights at Tom Sharkey's Athletic Club, where prospective fighters were made temporary "members" to circumvent the law. This painting, a follow-up to his earlier work "Stag at Sharkey's," showcases Bellows' signature style of dramatic chiaroscuro and vigorous brushwork, bringing the chaotic atmosphere to life.

Bellows had a knack for finding drama in everyday city life. What details in the crowd do you notice?

Details

So clubs like this one held secret fights.
So clubs like this one held secret fights.
Fighters became temporary "members" for the night.
Fighters became temporary "members" for the night.
The musculature and sweat-slicked skin are rendered with a visceral realism, highlighting the raw physicality of the sport.
The musculature and sweat-slicked skin are rendered with a visceral realism, highlighting the raw physicality of the sport.
Transcript

New York, 1909. Public boxing was illegal. So clubs like this one held secret fights. Fighters became temporary "members" for the night. This boxer's face shows the brutal reality. But the crowd relished every moment. The artist loved this raw, urban energy.