Artwork
Battle between the Jiccarilla Apachees and Camanchees
Battle between the Jiccarilla Apachees and Camanchees is an oil painting by the Impressionist artist George Catlin. It dates from 1865 and is held in the collection of the National Gallery of Art. Created in 1865, this oil painting on card mounted to paperboard portrays a violent encounter between Apache and Comanche warriors.
About this work
Subject & Meaning
Catlin's work idealizes the encounter through dynamic movement and stylized figures, emphasizing themes of frontier tension and cultural interaction.
The painting portrays a dramatic confrontation between Jiccarilla Apache and Comanche warriors, a scene reflecting 19th-century ethnographic interest in North American Indigenous conflicts. Catlin's work idealizes the encounter through dynamic movement and stylized figures, emphasizing themes of frontier tension and cultural interaction. The depiction of a tree serves as symbolic grounding, possibly representing natural order amid chaos.
Created in 1861, the oil on canvas captures a moment framed within the broader context of westward expansion and Indigenous displacement. The composition blends documentary intent with romanticized narrative, typical of history painting of the era. The artwork is housed in the National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., having entered the collection through the bequest of Paul Mellon in 1965.
The subject reflects Catlin's fascination with Native American life and his mission to document vanishing cultures, though his portrayal mixes observation with imaginative reconstruction. The tree motif, recurring in his works, may symbolize stability or ancestral presence amid violent upheaval. This narrative approach underscores the tension between ethnographic documentation and artistic interpretation in 19th-century American art.
Technique & Style
Created in 1861, this history painting is executed in oil on card that has been mounted onto a paperboard support. The work measures 45.9 cm in height and 61.9 cm in width. Stylistically, the composition incorporates natural elements, specifically depicting a tree within the scene of conflict between the Jiccarilla Apache and Comanche groups.
The piece is classified as a painting and remains part of the collection at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C.
History & Provenance
George Catlin painted Battle between the Jiccarilla Apachees and Camanchees in 1861 as an oil on card mounted on paperboard history painting. The work descended through Catlin's daughters Clara Gregory Catlin, Louise Catlin Kinney, and Elizabeth Wing Catlin before being purchased in 1912 from Elizabeth Wing Catlin by the American Museum of Natural History. Kennedy Galleries of New York sold the painting in 1959 to Paul Mellon of Upperville, VA, who gifted it to the National Gallery of Art in 1965 where it remains in the collection.
The painting is held by the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. It entered the collection through a gift in 1965 from Paul Mellon, having been acquired in 1959 from Kennedy Galleries and previously owned by Elizabeth Wing Catlin. The work was originally created by George Catlin in 1861 and passed by descent to his daughters before its purchase by the American Museum of Natural History in 1912.
Legacy
The painting's enduring legacy lies in its role as a historical record of Plains Indian warfare and its influence on documentation of Native American life. George Catlin's work, including this depiction of conflict between the Jiccarilla Apachees and Camanchees, contributed to early ethnographic visual archives now held at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. Its provenance from the artist's family to the museum in 1965 cemented its institutional significance as part of the NGA's foundational collection.
Overview
Created in 1865, this oil painting on card mounted to paperboard portrays a violent encounter between Apache and Comanche warriors. The composition centers on two mounted fighters locked in close combat, their horses kicking up dust as swords flash and feathers are tossed. The work functions as a historical record, capturing a rare clash that few contemporary sources document.
Own this work as a print
Artist & collection
Artist
George Catlin ( KAT-lin; July 26, 1796 – December 23, 1872) was an American lawyer, painter, author, and traveler, who specialized in portraits of Native Americans in the American frontier.
Bulls Fighting
Expedition Encamped on a Texas Prairie. April 1686
An Alligator's Nest
Mrs. George Catlin (Clara Bartlet Gregory)
Chief of the Taensa Indians Receiving La Salle. March 20, 1682
A Small Village - Payaguas Indians
Omaha Chief, His Wife, and a Warrior
Father Hennepin Leaving the Mississippi to Join La Salle. May 8, 1680
