Artwork
A Contest between the Shepherds Alcesto and Acaten
A Contest between the Shepherds Alcesto and Acaten is a tempera painting by the Italian Renaissance artist Master of 1416. It dates from 1410 and is held in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
About this work
Five figures gather in a rocky landscape. Two women in red and pink talk near a cave, a man leans on a rock with a staff, another kneels, and a fifth sits watching. A red border frames the scene. Painted on wood around 1410 by the Master of 1416.
Subject & Meaning
The painting illustrates a specific narrative scene identified as a contest between two shepherds, Alcesto and Acaten.
The painting illustrates a specific narrative scene identified as a contest between two shepherds, Alcesto and Acaten. This subject matter is derived from the Comedia delle ninfe fiorentine, a literary work by Giovanni Boccaccio. The iconography features male and female figures engaged in this pastoral competition, reflecting the themes of love and rural life common to the Florentine School of the early fifteenth century.
By depicting characters from Boccaccio's comedy, the work serves as a visual representation of contemporary humanist interest in classical and vernacular literature, translating a poetic contest into a tempera painting on wood.
Technique & Style
The work is executed in egg tempera on wood panel, consistent with Florentine practice of the early fifteenth century. Its small, intimate format (53.7 × 56.2 cm) and the Master of 1416's refined linear draftsmanship are evident in the delicate modeling of faces and drapery. The composition favors a shallow, stage-like space, with figures arranged in a frieze-like manner that emphasizes rhythmic contour over volumetric illusion. The palette relies on earthy greens, muted reds, and chalky whites, typical of the period's restrained colorism.
History & Provenance
The panel A Contest between the Shepherds Alcesto and Acaten is attributed to the Master of 1416 and dated to circa 1410, aligning with the artist's documented activity in Florence. The work is painted in tempera on wood and depicts a scene from Giovanni Boccaccio's Comedia delle ninfe fiorentine. It entered the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art through Charles Fairfax Murray, whose holdings formed part of the museum's early Florentine acquisitions.
The painting was later featured in exhibitions such as Florentine Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum and Art and Love in Renaissance Italy, confirming its institutional provenance within the museum's holdings.
The painting is currently held in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. Acquired through the bequest of Charles Fairfax Murray, the work is cataloged within the museum's holdings as a Florentine School piece executed in tempera on wood. The museum maintains the panel, which measures 53.7 by 56.2 centimeters.
The artwork has been featured in notable exhibitions, including "Florentine Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum" and "Art and Love in Renaissance Italy."
Overview
This painting, titled A Contest between the Shepherds Alcesto and Acaten, was created around 1410 by an artist known as the Master of 1416. Executed on wood, the work is a notable example from the early Florentine Quattrocento. It is currently housed in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, offering a glimpse into early 15th-century Florentine artistic production.
Context
As a product of the Florentine Quattrocento, this painting exemplifies the artistic trends emerging in Florence during the early 15th century. This period marked a significant shift in Italian art, characterized by a renewed interest in naturalism and classical themes, often integrated with narrative complexity. The Master of 1416's work contributes to the rich artistic heritage of the Florentine School, showcasing its early engagement with literary subjects and evolving visual language.
Own this work as a print
Artist & collection
Artist
An anonymous painter known only by a date, working on gilded wood panels. Ameto's Discovery of the Nymphs fills a golden forest with peeking nymphs and shepherds quarreling over love songs, the gold leaf bright and the…
- Ameto's Discovery of the Nymphs
Initial Q with a Procession of Children
The Meeting of Solomon and the Queen of Sheba; Cherub Holding Cornucopias of Cherries (recto and verso)
Garden of Love
Job Story: Message of Misfortune
Paradise
Christus am Ölberg
The Witch Anqarut ties Malik Iraj to a tree
Saint Lawrence Arraigned Before the Prefect Valerianus
Saint John the Baptist Preaching
A Pastoral Landscape with Shepherds Playing a Viola and Panpipes
Mythological Scene (Abduction of Europe?) – Fragment of a Cassone
